Tuesday, September 2, 2014

Follow Me, Brothers!



God’s grace, peace and mercy be with you. … My focus is on Matthew 16:24 and Romans 12:10. From Matthew, “Jesus told his disciples, ‘If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross and follow me.’” From Romans, “Love one another with brotherly affection.”
Let us pray. Heavenly Father, the psalmist wrote, “I rejoiced when they said to me, ‘Let us go to the house of the Lord.’”[1] Now that our feet are within your gates, we rejoice to hear your Word. As we listen, may your Spirit enlighten our minds and move our hearts to love deeply as Jesus loved. This we pray to you, Most Holy Trinity. Amen.
The cartoon depicts Jesus clarifying his statement to a would-be disciple, “No, I am not talking about Twitter. I literally want you to follow me.” The cartoon illustrates a lesson about language. Words change meaning overnight, over decades, centuries, and millennia. So, let me begin by examining a few words from our texts - from Matthew, follow, and from Paul, fraternal or brotherly affection. Then I will tell you how two war-torn enemies became brothers, setting an example for us.
First, follow. The cartoon quote is funny because one can misconstrue our Lord’s words as social media chatter. The word follow comes from the Old English folÄ¡ian or fylgan.[2] Follow has several meanings today. It means to come after in a sequence, such as B follows A in the alphabet. It means to go after, pursue or move behind in the same path or direction. Follow that car!
When you operate a new power tool, follow the instructions. Fans follow an event (World Cup), a team (Steelers), or an activity (You following me, camera guy?). As Jesus used the term, He was not reciting the alphabet or selling Sham Wows. He used follow to urge devotion to Him, His Way and His teaching.
People quit their careers and families to follow Jesus. His closest disciples sat at His feet.[3] They travelled by boat and foot to hear Him teach and witness Him heal. During His darkest moment, some followed at a distance and stood at the Foot of the Cross. A group followed His Body to the tomb and returned to anoint Him. After His Resurrection, the apostles followed Him to Bethany and stared into the sky as He ascended.[4]
Today’s passage, however, made it difficult for some to follow Jesus any further. It was the first time Jesus predicted His passion.
The passage also marks the turning point into the final section of Matthew, who wrote his Gospel for believers who knew the outcome of the story. Here, Matthew illustrated the reaction people had to Jesus’ revolutionary and unexpected teaching.
In its larger context, we see that Jesus’ original followers were common, ordinary men and women, but they knew and understood God’s plan for Israel and the world. They accepted Jesus’ teaching and witnessed the power of God working through Him. They saw His teaching and work evoked faith from the crowds and provoked persecution from religious and political authorities. With these parties plotting His demise, Jesus and His disciples retreated to a remote spot off the Sea of Galilee where He asked them who they believed Him to be.
Hearing the answer, Jesus showed His enlightened disciples what was required of Him – depart to Jerusalem to suffer many things from the elders, chief priests and scribes, be killed and raised on the third day.
Is it no wonder why – in this peaceful spot – Peter and the disciples reacted as they did? Why confront your enemies? Why provoke politicians? Why suffer? Why go to Jerusalem to be killed? These normal human theological questions arose from their sinful human minds. “If God’s mercy is to be found in Jerusalem’s Temple, then mercy and not murder awaits you there. That is how God works, Jesus!” said Peter, the man who declared Him the Messiah, the Son of the living God.
Peter was not simply confused, but took a firm stand against the Lord. Peter articulated God’s activity in the world in a satanic way, expressing the ‘things of men.’[5] When reprimanded, the only thing Peter could do was get out of Jesus’ way and not cause Him to stumble into disobedience that would have led to disaster for Israel’s lost sheep and the world. By getting out of the way, he learned what it meant to follow this Christ, this Son of God.[6]
Because His disciples misunderstood how God works in the world, verse 24 is the heart and summary of Jesus’ teaching. “If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross and follow me.” … Only by yielding to His Father’s will and His opponents, and accepting suffering and death by crucifixion could people and creation be saved from sin and death. That is how God works in the world.
The primary obstacle to following Jesus was not in the world, but deep within the heart of every disciple. They had to reject the tendency of insisting God conform to their ways and deal with evil according to their expectations. They had to reject the tendency that if in charge, they would make things right. They had to learn that criticism, competition or quiet, prideful comparison disguised as sinful human ambition embraced and exalted not the Cross of Christ, but them. “If anyone would come after me, let him deny himself and take up his cross and follow me.”
The first disciples who followed Jesus learned they could not pre-determine the type of difficulty, suffering or martyrdom they would face. As early Christians who worshipped the Trinity and renounced Greek and Roman gods, their neighbors hated and rejected them. Ultimately, some Christians found their way to crucifixion or some other gruesome form of death.
Peter deemed himself unworthy to die the same way as His Lord, and requested to be crucified upside-down. Others, like James, died by the sword,[7]
Of course, not all Christians were martyred. Christianity spread throughout the world, and to Rome, the setting for my second point, “Love one another with brotherly affection.”
Love one another with brotherly affection. Paul’s advice begs the question, “What was Paul trying to accomplish in these final chapters of Romans?” Paul was teaching Christians how to conduct their daily lives through the power and structure of grace.
Romans reveals God’s relationship to rebellious creation; how Christ reversed what Adam did; and how His death broke the power of sin. As human beings freed from the domination of sin and the law, we are now dominated by the Spirit. In chapter 9, Paul pointed towards the future and explained how from the beginning God’s plan of gracious election was at work, culminating in Christ who brought the law to an end by incorporating its goal in Him.
In chapter 12, Paul wrote about grace, which triumphed over human rebellion. Grace does not mean that anything goes. Rather, there is a structure to living the Christian life as individuals and communities. There is a structure to denying yourself, picking up your cross and following Christ.
If the Christian community responds appropriately to the structuring grace at work in it, it will display unity. Unity, however, is not uniformity, as Paul emphasized the necessity of diversity based on the abundance of God’s grace. Diversity is not simply a few people with special skills contributing to the community. All church members have spiritual gifts, and are responsible for discovering what gifts they have and use them to glorify God.[8]
In Rome, people mixed ego with grace. Some saw their gifts as more important than others’ gifts. That same problem arose in communities through 21 centuries across the globe. The solution to the problem of pride and over-inflated egos is love.[9]
Love one another with brotherly affection. That includes your enemies and those who displease you. Why? Because while we were enemies with God, we were reconciled to Him by the death of His Son.[10] The point of heaping burning coals on your enemy’s head is not to get back at him. Rather, you feed and refresh those who displease you because it is how Christians effect reconciliation with their enemies. A small gesture compared to how God effected reconciliation with us, His rebellious enemies.
Paul’s advice was not to withdraw from the world into seclusion as an individual or Christian enclave. Instead, Paul encouraged Christians in 1st century Rome to live among others, but with a different set of values. Attempting to reconcile and win over your enemies through kindness, compassion and brotherly love was not an action people embraced, but Christians did.
Christians of 1st century Rome believed Jesus Christ died for their sins and rose from the dead. They believed that they, once rebellious enemies of God, were reconciled through Christ’s death and resurrection. When the Paschal Mystery is embedded in your heart, mind and soul, you do what God asks or commands. You even deny yourself, take up your cross and follow Christ by loving your enemies with brotherly affection.
All well and good, but what do the readings have to do with life today? How do we deny ourselves, pick up our cross and follow Jesus? How do we love enemies with brotherly love?
Let me tell you a story of two men, intent on killing one another in war, who became as close as brothers. While serving as pastor in Oakmont, PA, I met Howard Hamilton in the spring of 1998. By December, he died from a long illness, but he should have died in 1943. Instead, he and his wife, Gerri, had three sons and a daughter, and Howard, after a distinguished career in manufacturing, became professor of electrical engineering at the University of Pittsburgh.
You see, during World War II, on his 19th mission as a bombardier in the Army Air Corps, Howard’s B-17 was hit by enemy fire on October 10th. It punctured his lung. He lost consciousness and regained it only to have his parachute pack strap catch on the door handle. He dangled as the plane spiraled. He did not have enough strength to free himself. His co-pilot risked his life to set him free.
Howard landed in a tree. The Germans captured him and took him to a hospital where he lay on a stretcher for 12 hours until an officer in charge of prisoners of war begged the one lone surgeon to treat him because he would die before morning.
In captivity for 19 months, initially in a hospital and then in Stalag Luft on the Baltic Sea, he was liberated by the Russians on May 1, 1945. After the war, Howard went to college on the GI bill, began his career and family.
Howard lived a successful life professionally and personally, but that is not why I tell you this story. You see, Howard and the German officer who begged that he be treated did not forget each other. The officer looked him up after reading a book about the raid. The Hamilton’s visited him in Germany, and he visited them in Pittsburgh.[11]
If two men, intent on killing one another, can reconcile and treat one another with brotherly love, who of us cannot reconcile with people we dislike and love them, as Christians should?
Friends, we may never fly as bombardiers, encounter our enemy on a gurney, or spend years as a P.O.W., but we have relatives and neighbors, co-workers and colleagues, who wronged us. Some owe us money because they rent space in our heads. And although sin keeps me from reconciling, I bear the cross of reconciliation behind Christ. Because of Him and His grace, we can reconcile with people we dislike because God reconciled with us when we were enemies.
This week, treat one person you dislike with brotherly love, and when you do, may the peace of God that surpasses all understanding, keep your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus. Amen.


[1] Psalm 122
[3] Luke 10:39.
[4] Luke 24:50-51
[5] Jeffrey A. Gibbs, Matthew 11:2- 20:34. St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House (2010), 840.
[6] Ibid.
[7] Acts 12:2
[8] Paul J. Achtemeier, Romans. Louisville: John Knox Press (1985), 196f.
[9] Ibid, 198.
[10] Romans 5:9-10
[11] Eleanor Chute, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette Education Writer.  Obituary: Howard Britton Hamilton. Wednesday, December 02, 1998.  http://old.post-gazette.com/regionstate/19981202hamilton9.asp

Saturday, August 23, 2014

Another Chapter



Hey, friends.

Cindy and I start a new chapter in our lives beginning this week. I accepted the position of Vacancy Pastor at Trinity Church in Nashville, Illinois. At least through January 31, 2015, we will be living at the parsonage. Our personal address is:

614 W. Walnut Street
Nashville IL 62263.

At the church office, you can reach me by phone, e-mail, or regular mail.

Trinity Lutheran Church
680 W. Walnut St.
Nashville, IL  62263 

Phone: 618-327-3311
Fax: 618-327-8561
E-mail: trinitystjohn@gmail.com
Office hours: 8 am - 4 pm (Monday to Friday)
The church’s website is http://trinity-nashville.org/.

You can also keep in touch via email or social media sites – Facebook, Twitter, LinkedIn, Google+, Yelp, Foursquare, Tumblr, Pinterest or my blog, http://cwynar.blogspot.com/.

If you are driving through Illinois, we live 5 miles south of I-64, and 55 miles east of St. Louis. Let us know if you need a place to sleep overnight. We have plenty of room.

Please continue to pray for us. God bless your week.

Paul and Cindy Cwynar

Sunday, July 13, 2014

Grace Trumps Efficiency



God’s grace, peace and mercy be with you. … My focus is Romans 8:15, “For you did not receive a spirit that makes you a slave again to fear, but you received the Spirit of sonship,” and Matthew 13:3, “Then Jesus told them many things in parables, saying: “A farmer went out to sow his seed.”
Let us pray. Heavenly Father, the psalmist wrote, “I rejoiced when they said to me, ‘Let us go to the house of the Lord.’”[1] Now that our feet are within your gates, we rejoice to hear your Word. As we listen, may your Spirit enlighten our minds and move our hearts to love deeply as Jesus loved. This we pray to you, Most Holy Trinity. Amen.
“I to I” stood for “Incarceration to Independence.” “I to I” was a program I started in 2004 for young mothers incarcerated at the Allegheny County Jail in Pittsburgh. The goal of “I to I” was to offer a seamless transition from a woman’s incarceration into society where as an independent woman, she could resume her duties of motherhood.
In the year that I initiated and oversaw “I to I,” more than 50 women sought assistance. Our most successful client was Eva. In fact, Eva was our only successful client. Despite all I did for my clients – counseling, suitable clothing for court, personal transportation to their parole officer, to Bethlehem Haven or POWER (organizations that work with homeless women), and connecting them to a myriad of social services, my ministry was a failure. Of 50 women, one succeeded.
I failed because I was working with incarcerated women, including those with babies, who were addicted to some drug that stemmed from abuse or neglect as children. They were arrested for crimes related to their addiction – possession, theft, solicitation or some other non-violent crime.
In 1970, there were 5,600 women incarcerated in all US prisons. By 2001, there were 160,000 incarcerated women. Presently, the prison population has over 2 million women.[2] Is there a need for programs such as “I to I” today? Definitely. Will such programs produce successful women such as Eva? Undoubtedly. Will the majority of incarcerated women transition to independence? No. Then, why support such programs? In a word, grace.
I relate my experience of “I to I” to Romans and Matthew for two reasons. First, our understanding of addiction helps us grasp Paul’s theology of sin and grace, or fear and sonship. Second, failure offers us understanding of the Sower and the Seed, and the parable offers us hope.
First, Paul’s theology of sin and grace. Paul used “slave” in Romans to teach Christians how sin, the flesh or the ways of the world enslaved us. He also used the word to describe our relationship with God. As heirs of God and co-heirs of Christ, we are slaves of righteousness.
We do not have a personal experience of being slaves, and few of us have ever met a slave, although there are more than 15,000 slaves trafficked in our nation annually.[3] So, when Paul writes of slaves of sin or fear and slaves of righteousness, we do not grasp the meaning.
A slave has a master. Society teaches me that I do not have a master. I am master of my own destiny. No one tells me how to live, how to think, how to behave. I am my own man. That makes it difficult to grasp the meaning of Paul’s theology of sin.
We might understand Paul better if we consider ourselves not as slaves but as addicts. Our experience of addiction is real. We know addicts. Whether our experience of an addict is an incarcerated mother, someone in our school or in our family, or even personal, we know addicts.
Today, we know addicts as people dependent on drugs or alcohol to cope with life, but in the Roman Empire, addicts were bankrupt people given as slaves to their creditors. Addict comes from the Latin addictus, meaning, “a debtor awarded as a slave to his creditor.” In the 1600s, it meant giving yourself to someone or some practice. By the 1900s, addict became associated with dependency on drugs.
So, when Paul says we are slaves of fear or slaves to sin, he means that we are addicted to sin. This addiction to sin extends beyond acts of murder, theft, adultery or gossip, and goes to the heart of sin – idolatry. … The heart of sin is not having God rule my life. I am addicted to thinking that I control my destiny. God is not my master. I have no master. I am my own master.
From his encounter with the Risen Christ, Paul knew better. As sinners whose debt was paid through the death and resurrection of Christ Jesus, we, the baptized, should live as addicts of the Holy Trinity. We are addicted to God. As a drug controls the life of an addict, the Trinity controls the life of a Christian. Addiction to God leads me to my next point, failure.
Failure offers us understanding of the Sower and the Seed, and it offers us hope. … To develop this point, we examine the parable in its fuller context. Matthew opens the chapter with the words, “on that day.” What happened on that day? Before the parable, that is, in chapter 12, we read that the Pharisees claimed the source of Jesus’ power was Beelzebul; teachers of the law demanded a sign; and his family did not grasp his identity.
At the end of chapter 13, His scandalized homefolk questioned the source of Jesus’ wisdom and power. The closing verse reads, “He did not do many miracles there because of their lack of faith.”[4]
Reading the wider passage helps us understand why Jesus spoke these parables. Despite his teaching and his healing, despite opening people’s minds and hearts, so many failed to respond in faith and discipleship.
True, Satan, sin and the world devoured His message as birds feed on seed so that before Jesus proclaimed the reign of God His hearers never had a chance to understand or believe it.[5] Some new believers and followers of Jesus, like seed on rocky ground, who did not put down deep roots, experienced personal difficulties or opposition because of their belief, and turned away. Others, like seed among thorns, were seduced by wealth or let worry asphyxiate the Good News of God’s power. In short, most seed produced no fruit.
Most seed produced no fruit because God came in mysteriously lowly, weak and resistible ways. … God comes in mysteriously lowly, weak and resistible ways, but those who have ears hear Him. During Jesus’ life, some heard the Good News of how God the King was coming to reclaim creation and forgive His people. They heard and understood, and in their understanding, they were fruitful for God. Peter and Paul, Martha and Mary, tax collectors Matthew and Zaccheus, fishermen James and John, and others heard and understood Jesus.
What did they hear and understand? … Scrape away the top layer of our text to examine the Sower’s methods, and notice that He, God, throws His seed on the path where birds eat it, on rocky soil where roots wither, among thorns and on good soil. In other words, God sows seed everywhere. God does not restrict His seed, His message, to a particular plot of land or a specific group of people. God’s indiscriminate broadcast of seed or grace is not efficient and goes against the human tendency to conserve one’s resources and efforts. God’s method is not efficient or productive, but in the Reign of God, grace trumps efficiency. God’s message, God’s grace, God’s forgiveness, God’s love is for all people.
Now, compare the fruit that fell on good soil to the seed that produced none. Ask yourself how that seed produced faith that has lasted for 2,000 years and blossomed in every nation and culture. This occurred not by reason or sheer human willpower. As Martin Luther’s Small Catechism explained the Third Article of the Apostle’s Creed, “I believe that I cannot by my own reason or strength believe in Jesus Christ my Lord, or come to Him; but the Holy Spirit has called me by the Gospel.”[6]
The Holy Spirit called me by the Gospel. We believe in the Holy Spirit because by our own reason or strength we cannot believe in Jesus Christ our Lord. Those who heard and understood Jesus allowed the Holy Spirit to enter their hearts.
The Holy Spirit also empowered Jesus, when faced with failure, not to abandon His Father’s will. Even though the Pharisees, His family and friends thought He was possessed or crazy, Jesus did not abandon His mission. He continued to spread His Good News. He continued to spread His Gospel like a farmer sowing seed. Jesus sowed seeds of faith, hope and love. Among the hopeless, Jesus sowed seeds of hope. Among the unloved, Jesus sowed seeds of love. Among those struggling with faith, Jesus prayed that the Holy Spirit enlighten their minds and move their hearts.
So, how does the parable offer us hope today?
I should have given up on Eva. I worked with 50 women, and 49 failed. However, by grace, Eva succeeded. I spent countless hours on the phone and in person counseling Eva. I visited her in jail. When released, I got her into Bethlehem Haven, an organization that assists homeless women in recovery. I listened to her complaints and disappointments. I met her children. I secured furniture for her first apartment. And then, I moved to California.
Two years later, my former boss, Liguori Rossner, told me that Eva greeted her as her host at a local restaurant. Eva was thrilled to see Liguori and expressed joyful gratitude for all that I did for her. People may say that “I to I” failed, but Eva did not.
Our work with her – all for the glory of God – produced more fruit than imaginable. Honestly, I thought the birds of prey would snatch away the Good News or the worries of life would choke her, but the Spirit worked in her and I am grateful to God for that.
God may not be calling you to minister to incarcerated women, but God is calling you to demonstrate the fruits of His seed, His grace and love. God calls you to show how His loving-kindness has changed your life. He calls you to read, study and pray His Word. He calls you to receive His grace poured into your heart through the Sacraments of Baptism and Communion. Through the power of the Holy Spirit, the Father and Son call you to demonstrate His presence in your life.
If God called you to parent, raise your children as baptized Christians. If God called you to marriage, love your spouse as Christ loves His spouse, the Church. If God called you to teach, inspire students. If God called you to the military or public service, serve under the banner of Christ. If God called you to business or industry, do business with Christian ethics.
Fear not those who steal the Gospel like birds of prey. Let not the world or its worries stifle God’s Spirit in you. In Paul’s words, “You who have received the Spirit of sonship will never again be a slave to fear.”[7]
Offer hope to the hopeless, love the unloved, evangelize without words. Offer this world’s Eva’s another chance.
Be not a Christian comfortable living the ways of the world, the ways of flesh. If you melded your faith into the world’s ways ... If you are satisfied with your relationship with God … If you are living a “respectable” Christian life, consider these words of the recently passed Chuck Noll, the only NFL coach to win four Super Bowls. Asked at his first news conference if his goal was to make the Steelers respectable, Noll said, “Respectability? Who wants to be respectable? That's spoken like a true loser.”[8]
Be a champion for Christ. Witness for Christ, and not Satan, sin and self. … Witness for Christ like an addict, like an heir of the Kingdom. Spread seeds of faith, hope and love everywhere and without discrimination. And when you do, the peace of God that surpasses all understanding, will keep your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus. Amen.


[2] Inside and Out: Women, Prison, and Therapy  edited by Elaine J. Leeder. Taylor and Francis, 2007.
[4] Matthew 13:58
[5] Jeffrey A. Gibbs, Matthew 11:2-20:34. St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 2010, p. 681.
[6] Luther’s Small Catechism with Explanation, p. 15.
[7] Paraphrasing Romans 8:15